Initially our intention was to compare every kind of Bluetooth
headset and headphones available. As we were using the headphones in our
day-to-day lives, we realized that certain headsets were better
designed for particular functions. Optimizing a product design for one
usage often involved degrading important characteristics of another
function. This is analogous to building a car. If you want something
fast that can go from 0-60 is 4 seconds flat; it's probably not going to
get the best gas mileage, or be of much use hauling 3 kids around town.
The bottom line is those who want the best headphones for listening to
music, or watching videos, have a different product profile than mobile
warriors looking to make VOIP calls (more on this topic at the end).
In
this product comparison, we are looking for the best Bluetooth
headphones to listen to music and watch movies on your iPad. While we
emphasized sound quality for music and video playback, virtually all the
Bluetooth headsets have built in microphones and VOIP capability. Next
week we will have a product comparison for Bluetooth headsets designed
primarily for voice conversations that are iPad compatible, and play
stereo sound.
The criteria for our product recommendations are
sound quality, fit/comfort, battery life, features, and build quality.
The greatest weight is our scoring was given to sound quality (approx
40% of the weighting); with the other 4 categories given weights equally
divided with the remaining allocation. All the Bluetooth headsets
recommended were tested with both the iPad 1 and iPad 2 running iOS
versions as early as 4.2. Going back to our car analogy, you cannot
expect an inexpensive car like a Ford Focus to compare with the
performance of a high end car like a Ferrari. With that in mind, we also
broke our recommendations into the best iPad Bluetooth headphones
within a given price range.
One last tip before we begin is there
no such thing as a Bluetooth headset designed for just the iPad. So if
you are browsing online, or walking through the aisles of Best Buy
looking for products with the words "iPad Bluetooth Headsets" scrawled
on the packaging, you will be severely limiting your selection. When
shopping for a Bluetooth headset or headphones for your iPad, just look
make sure it's a stereo headset or A2DP capable. The Bluetooth headset
you buy for your iPad should work with your cell phone and Bluetooth
enabled computer as well.
Best Bluetooth Headsets for your iPad under $40: Arctic Sound P311
Arctic Sound P311 (MSRP $39.99)
Overview:
Our
winner for the best Bluetooth headset under $40 is the Arctic Sound
P311. If you are a techie the name will sound familiar as Arctic Sound
is a division of Arctic Cooling, a Swiss owned company that makes CPU
cooling and computer accessories. While the MSRP of the P311 is $39.95,
you will find this headset online for around $30. It does everything you
want out of a headset at a fair price. We loved this headset over more
expensive Motorola and Sony models. Sound quality was indistinguishable
from the Motorola and Sony models but the features that won us over were
the amazing battery life and the folding design. In addition to testing
it with the iPad, we were able to pair this headset with a PlayStation
3, laptops (MAC & PC), Android Phone, iPhone, and Nokia Phone with
no problems.
Sound Quality
We paired the Arctic Sound P311
with an Android phone, iPhone, and Nokia to test sound quality when
making phone calls. Our friends on the other end could hear us just
fine. Sound quality was crisp and there was no lag or choppiness in the
conversation. For VOIP and cellular pairing, the P311 includes a hidden
integrated microphone, built-in sound processor, and Advanced Clear
Voice Capture (CVC) technology. The latter is just a fancy way of saying
noise cancelling technology. While the microphone picks up on your
voice during calls exquisitely, the noise cancelling function is not on
par with higher end headsets such as the newest model Jawbone or
Plantronic headsets. If you plan on speaking with a person in a noisy
place such as Starbucks during the morning rush, the background noise
will bleed into the conversation more than the high end headsets.
For
music and video playback the sound was excellent for a device of this
class. The music was crisp and vibrant at higher range. The built in
high fidelity drivers were able to process sound in low range without
any cracks or squeaks. The bass does sound flat when compared to higher
end headsets and surround sound speakers. These are not the headsets to
do sound editing on your MacBook Pro, but if you are watching Netflix on
your iPad or listening to your iPod app, sound quality is excellent.
Fit/Comfort
Weighing
just 2.5 ounces, the P311 is very light. The closed acoustic ear cups
provides good comfort as we could where them all day without a fatigue
or irritation. Some of our readers might not like the behind the ear
design but we found this ideal if you are planning to use these headsets
at work, as they will not mess up the hair like over-the-head headsets.
Features
One
of the most useful features is the right earphone has 5 buttons that
control certain settings. They allow you to answer a call, adjust the
volume and forward/reverse the music. The device you pair the headset
with must allow these functions but we found most do. If paired with a
cell phone and there is an incoming call, the Inter-Call-Manager will
play a ringtone into the headset. The music will then be paused and will
resume after ending the call. Pairing to my iPad was not a problem and
the controls worked for volume, skip, reverse, and pause. The Antic
Sound P311 does not support multipoint Bluetooth.
Battery Life
The Arctic Sound P311 has a built in
rechargeable 400mAH lithium polymer battery similar to the lithium
polymer technology Apples uses for the iPad and MacBooks. The
manufacturer claims up to 20 hours of listening/talk time for the Arctic
Silver but you can only achieve that time under very unrealistic
circumstances. When talking on the headset for over an hour and spending
the rest of the time listening to music at mid volume, we averaged
12-14 hours per charge. While not the 20 hours claimed by the
manufacture, this was enough for a full day's work and double the
battery life of other headsets. Mobile warriors will love that the
Arctic Sound P311 headset charges via mini USB instead of a proprietary
design. If have a Blackberry, you can use that AC Adapter or USB cable
to charge the headset leaving one less item to lug around. Charging time
starting from a dead battery is about 4 hours. A USB cable is provided
for you to plug into your computer or iPad AC adapter.
Build Quality:
The
Arctic Sound P311 comes with a nylon hard case so they easily tuck away
safely in your briefcase, purse, or backpack. The headphones themselves
are made from hardened plastic. Because of its folding design, it can
be damaged if you too much force is applied against the hinges. By no
means does it make the headsets fragile as the headset was dropped
accidentally a few times without any damage.
Bluetooth Compatibility: Bluetooth v2.1 + EDR, A2DP, AVRCP, HSP, HFP 1.5
Honorable Mention:
Jabra CLIPPER Bluetooth Stereo Headset (Ear bud Style)
Best Bluetooth Headsets for your iPad under $100: Plantronics Backbeat 903+
Plantronics Backbeat 903+ (MSRP $99.99)
Overview:
The
Plantronics Backbeat 903+ is the upgrade for Plantronics best selling
903/906 series. The Backbeat 903+ was released last year incorporating
the newer Bluetooth standards. The most important feature this headset
has over the Arctic Sound P311 is the multipoint Bluetooth technology.
What multipoint allows you to do is pair two Bluetooth devices with one
headset. As long as your devices support multipoint, you can pair your
cell phone to the Backbeat 903+ while streaming audio from your iPad.
Most new phones support multipoint including the Android and Blackberry
platforms. Both the iPhone and iPad support multipoint as long as you
are running iOS version 4.1 and above.
Why is multipoint so
important? If you have multipoint, you will not miss a call if you are
listening to music on your iPad or iPod! If your iPhone rings while your
blasting away Metallica on your iPad, the Backbeat 903+ supporting
multipoint will pause the music, and notify you of an incoming call. The
one touch features on the Backbeat 903+ will allow you to answer the
phone without having to physically answer it.
We recommend not paying MSRP by searching online for the best deal. We bought our Backbeat 903+ on Amazon for $69.99.
Sound Quality
In
terms of sound quality when making phone calls, the Plantronics
Backbeat 903+ is superior to the Arctic Sound P311. This is the result
of the superior noise cancelling feature and windshield. The headset has
two microphones instead of just one. Both microphones are positioned be
shielded from direct wind. Plantronics calls their noise cancelling
technology AudioIQ2. Basically what happens is they microphones pick of
your voice and digitally erase the background noise to provide a
superior phone conversation.
The Backbeat 903+ has a rich and
vibrant sound, and can stream music, video, and app sounds from your
iPad. The headset has an enhanced bass that provides a deeper, and more
earth moving feeling than the P311. While the Backbeat 903+ does have
noise cancelling technology, it should be noted that it is for voice
calls and not streaming music.
Fit/Comfort
Like the Arctic
Sound headset, the Plantronics 903+ is a behind the ear design with
close fitting earpieces. Each earpiece adjusts three ways for a custom
fit.
Features
The Backbeat 903+ has a unique technology
called OpenMic that allows you to hear what's going on around you with a
touch of a button. The Backbeat also supports one touch controls
allowing you to start/end calls, and control music functions such as
volume and pause/play. Voice alerts tell you if there is a low battery,
when there is an incoming call, and when you have lost a phone
connection. You can also monitor the battery level of the headset on
your iPhone with built-in software. And as discussed earlier, the
Backbeat 903+ supports multipoint allowing you to connect to your cell
phone and iPad simultaneously.
Battery Life
Battery life
provides 7 hours talk time. Standby time is 7 Hours. Charge time is 3
hours and the charging interface is micro USB. An AC Adapter is
provided.
Build Quality
The Backbeat is constructed of high
impact plastic designed for more abuse than a typical headset. If you
are runner or plan to use the Backbeat in the gym, you will love its
sturdiness and flexibility. The headphones can folded up and a soft
protective bag is provided.
Honorable Mention:
Sony DR-BT100CX Ear Bud Style Stereo Bluetooth Headset